Tennis news desk

Match Analysis

John Isner says Carlos Alcaraz serve is not top-10

John Isner claims Carlos Alcaraz's serve lacks elite polish despite the Spaniard's recent titles in Vienna and Paris. ATP stats show Alcaraz ranks 13th in Serve Rating, with 4.8 aces per match, though he has adjusted his motion to improve.

Published
Reading time
2 minutes
John Isner says Carlos Alcaraz serve is not top-10

John Isner, one of the biggest servers in tennis history, claims Carlos Alcaraz’s serve is "not a top-10 serve by any means." The world No. 3 heads to the ATP Finals in Turin on the back of titles in Vienna and Paris, yet the American sees a clear area for improvement. Isner pointed to Novak Djokovic as proof that a serve can be transformed during a career, noting that Djokovic improved his service game late in his career and "just went boom." This assessment comes from the latest episode of the Nothing Major podcast, where Isner argued that Alcaraz’s current delivery lacks the polish of the tour’s elite servers.

Statistical reality checks the hype

ATP statistics over the past 52 weeks partly back Isner up, though they cover most of the year before Alcaraz adjusted his motion. The Spaniard ranks 13th on the tour in the ATP’s Serve Rating, a figure that obscures significant internal disparities. He sits inside the top 10 for first serves in (7th), second-serve points won (8th) and service games won (6th). However, he is only 39th for first-serve points won and 59th for aces per match, with an average of just 4.8. These numbers suggest that while his overall consistency is high, his power and precision on the initial strike remain inconsistent compared to dedicated specialists.

Alcaraz already at work

Alcaraz has not waited for external advice to refine his technique. Ahead of the Laver Cup in September, he adjusted his service motion by using a lower ball toss and changing the position of his left foot. In a recent press conference, the Spaniard explained that he wanted to copy what he had seen in the greatest servers, emphasizing that "the toss and the balance are everything on the serve." He reported feeling much better on the serve, stating that viewers could see a great improvement in Vienna. In Paris, Alcaraz beat Alex Michelsen, Taylor Fritz, Casper Ruud and Ben Shelton on his way to the title. The ATP Finals start on Sunday, November 15, with the group draw on Thursday.