Tennis news desk

Players

Brenda Patea sues Alexander Zverev over innocence claims

Lawyers for Brenda Patea filed a civil complaint in Berlin seeking 250,000 euros in damages from Alexander Zverev. The lawsuit follows an interview where Zverev claimed his innocence, despite the criminal proceedings being terminated without a finding of guilt.

Published
Reading time
2 minutes
Brenda Patea sues Alexander Zverev over innocence claims

Patea seeks damages and an injunction

Lawyers for Brenda Patea filed a civil complaint in Berlin in September against world number one Alexander Zverev following an interview he gave to the French newspaper L’Equipe in June. This interview included a claim that the player allegedly said "my innocence has been proven". Patea is seeking damages and an injunction that would impose a fine of up to 250,000 euros (£209,000) if Zverev repeats this claim. Michael Scheele, the lawyer for Patea, stated that the player was not acquitted and that both parties signed an agreement in which Zverev committed not to talk about the case any more. Patea, who works as a content creator and influencer, claims she received no money from the settlement because the payment Zverev made only concerned their daughter. She also notes that accusations of her trying to make money from the situation were false. I find the claim that Zverev’s comments impact her career to be the core of this legal friction.

Defense cites freedom of opinion

Schertz Bergmann, the Berlin law firm representing Zverev, will defend him against the lawsuit and argues that any such statement is a permissible expression of opinion protected by Article 5(1) of the German Basic Law. The firm said the player merely expressed a personal conviction that he did everything in his power to refute the allegations and he considers his innocence to have been confirmed by the outcome of the criminal proceedings. The firm also said that the presumption of innocence remains unaffected because the criminal proceedings were discontinued without any finding of guilt. This legal battle follows a June 2024 trial in Berlin where the court terminated the proceedings after Patea expressed a wish to end the trial and the defendant agreed to the termination. The court also noted a separate settlement between Zverev and Patea in June 2024. In October 2023, Zverev received a penalty order for bodily harm against Patea. The court told the BBC that the decision is not a verdict or a decision about guilt or innocence. Zverev previously told BBC Sport, "That’s what dropping the case is. That is innocence," adding that he never ever wants to hear another question about the subject again. I think the legal distinction between a terminated case and an acquittal makes this lawsuit a predictable mess.